The Best Security Rating Tools for Small Businesses (2027): What They Measure, What They Cost, and Our Pick

Your customers, suppliers and insurer can already grade your security from the outside. We compared the security rating tools a small business is most likely to meet, what each one measures, whether you can see your own rating for free, and what the paid plans cost.

By CyberScore Labs · Updated

What is the best security rating tool for a small business?

The best-known security rating tools in 2027 are CyberScore Labs, Bitsight, Black Kite, Panorays, RiskRecon, SecurityScorecard and UpGuard. CyberScore Labs is our pick for small businesses: one free check grades your email security, website, known vulnerabilities and exposed services in about 60 seconds, explains every finding in plain English with the exact fix, needs no credit card and never sends attack traffic. The others are built mainly for enterprise vendor-risk teams; SecurityScorecard and UpGuard also let you see your own rating for free.

Key facts

  • Security ratings are built from outside-in data: anyone can rate your company without your permission or access to your systems.
  • SecurityScorecard and UpGuard let any company see its own rating for free; Bitsight sends a one-off report on request.
  • Of the six enterprise vendors we checked, only UpGuard publishes prices, from $1,667 a month billed annually.
  • In the UK, 46% of small businesses reported a breach or attack in the last 12 months (Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025/2026).
  • CyberScore Labs grades email security, website, known vulnerabilities and exposed services for free, with the fix for each finding.

Security rating tools at a glance

CyberScore Labs first as our pick, then the others A to Z. Not a ranking.

ToolBest forWhat it checksFree optionPaid plans
CyberScore LabsSmall businesses that want their own grade, in plain English, with the fix for each findingEmail security (SPF, DMARC, DKIM, MTA-STS, TLS-RPT), website, known vulnerabilities and exposed servicesFree. Needs your domain and an email address for the report; no credit cardNone: the check is free. Help fixing what it finds is optional, on request
BitsightOrganisations that need a credit-score-style number to benchmark against peers and insurersCompromised systems, user behaviour, diligence (e.g. TLS, open ports, patching cadence) and public disclosuresA one-off emailed rating report for your own organisation, by request formNot published (sales quote)
Black KiteVendor-risk teams that want ratings expressed in dollars and ransomware likelihoodTwenty technical categories in four groups: safeguard, privacy, resiliency and reputationA free cyber risk assessment form, framed around assessing a vendorNot published (demo first)
PanoraysTeams that want outside-in ratings and vendor questionnaires combined into one scoreNetwork and IT (web, email and DNS servers, TLS, cloud), applications and the human attack surfaceA free account to send up to five questionnaires and see five third partiesNot published (custom quote)
RiskReconVendor-risk programmes that want issues ranked by the value of the system affectedExternally visible systems and issues, prioritised by severity and the value at risk of each systemA 30-day trial: ratings for up to 50 vendors plus a report on your own organisationNot published
SecurityScorecardSeeing, and disputing, the grade your customers and partners may already see about youTen categories such as DNS health, IP reputation and patching cadence, from an outside-in scanA free-forever account with a rating for your own domain and alerts when it changesNot published (sales quote, priced mainly by how many organisations you monitor)
UpGuardA published rating method, a free instant score, and list prices you can see before a callTen risk categories of internet-facing assets, such as email security, SSL, DNS health and vulnerabilitiesA free instant security score by short form, and a free website scanFrom $1,750 a month (Vendor Risk) or $1,667 a month (Breach Risk), billed annually

Why CyberScore Labs is our pick

Most security rating platforms were built for large companies to grade their suppliers. CyberScore Labs is built the other way round: for the small business being graded, so it can see what an outsider sees and fix it before a customer, a partner or an insurer asks.

You type your domain and an email address, and about a minute later you have a letter grade from A to F, a list of findings in plain English, and for each one the exact setting your IT person or web host needs to change. It reads only what is already public: DNS records, your certificate, a handful of ordinary web requests (about what one visitor makes), certificate transparency logs and what Shodan already sees on your servers. It never logs in, never scans your ports and never sends attack traffic.

What it does not do, so you can plan around it: it does not test behind a login, exploit anything, scan ports itself, watch breach databases, scan for malware or run a penetration test. For those you need one of the paid tools below, or a security firm.

  • One check, four areas

    Email security, your website, known vulnerabilities and exposed services in one free scan that takes about 60 seconds.

  • Plain English, with the exact fix

    A grade, findings a non-technical owner can read, and the exact setting for your IT person or web host to change.

  • Free, no card, non-invasive

    Free with no credit card. It reads public records only: it never logs in, never scans your ports and never sends attack traffic.

  • Vulnerability data updated daily

    Your server software, CMS, WordPress plugins and JavaScript libraries are matched daily against endoflife.date, NVD, OSV and CISA’s list of actively exploited flaws.

Check your domain free

Other security rating tools, and what each is best for

Listed A to Z. Each one is good at something; pick by what you need.

Bitsight

by Bitsight (Boston, MA)

Best for: Organisations that need a credit-score-style number to benchmark against peers and insurers

Known for
  • A rating on a 250 to 900 scale that Bitsight compares to a credit score; the range currently achievable is 300 to 820.
  • Ratings refreshed daily from sources such as crawlers, sinkholes, honeypots and spam traps.
  • Moody's became its largest shareholder, with a minority stake, after investing $250 million in 2021.
Good to know
  • The free option is a single emailed report behind a sales and marketing form, not ongoing self-monitoring.
  • The platform is sold to enterprise security, vendor-risk and insurance teams on a quote basis.

Free option: A one-off emailed rating report for your own organisation, by request form · Paid: Not published (sales quote)

Visit Bitsight

Black Kite

by Black Kite

Best for: Vendor-risk teams that want ratings expressed in dollars and ransomware likelihood

Known for
  • An A to F letter grade built from 20 technical categories, with patch management weighted most.
  • A method based on MITRE's Cyber Threat Susceptibility Assessment, with Open FAIR financial-impact estimates.
  • A Ransomware Susceptibility Index alongside the letter grade.
Good to know
  • Built for third-party risk programmes; we found no clear self-serve way for a small business to check itself.
  • Sales start with a booked demo.

Free option: A free cyber risk assessment form, framed around assessing a vendor · Paid: Not published (demo first)

Visit Black Kite

Panorays

by Panorays (New York, NY)

Best for: Teams that want outside-in ratings and vendor questionnaires combined into one score

Known for
  • A 0 to 100 Cyber Posture Rating from externally available data, adjusted for company size and industry.
  • A combined score that merges the outside-in rating with questionnaire answers.
  • Mapping of third, fourth and further parties in a supply chain.
Good to know
  • A vendor-risk tool first: the free account is for watching suppliers, not for rating yourself.
  • Pricing depends on your risk programme and is quoted on request.

Free option: A free account to send up to five questionnaires and see five third parties · Paid: Not published (custom quote)

Visit Panorays

RiskRecon

by RiskRecon, a Mastercard company (Salt Lake City, UT)

Best for: Vendor-risk programmes that want issues ranked by the value of the system affected

Known for
  • Owned by Mastercard, which announced the acquisition in December 2019.
  • Ratings from 0 to 10, grouped into A to F bands (A is 8.5 to 10).
  • Issues prioritised by how valuable the affected system is, not just by severity.
Good to know
  • Free access is a time-limited trial with a verification step, not a free-forever view of your own rating.
  • Built for teams managing a portfolio of vendors.

Free option: A 30-day trial: ratings for up to 50 vendors plus a report on your own organisation · Paid: Not published

Visit RiskRecon

SecurityScorecard

by SecurityScorecard

Best for: Seeing, and disputing, the grade your customers and partners may already see about you

Known for
  • A to F letter grades across ten categories, from a scan it says covers 4.1 billion IPs and domains.
  • A free account for any organisation to see its own rating and dispute findings.
  • Says it monitors and rates more than 12 million organisations.
Good to know
  • The paid product, TITAN, is built for vendor-risk teams and priced by sales quote.
  • The free tier covers your own domain; monitoring many companies and the deeper features are paid.

Free option: A free-forever account with a rating for your own domain and alerts when it changes · Paid: Not published (sales quote, priced mainly by how many organisations you monitor)

Visit SecurityScorecard

UpGuard

by UpGuard (founded 2012)

Best for: A published rating method, a free instant score, and list prices you can see before a call

Known for
  • A rating out of 950: each asset starts at 950 and loses points for every failed check, weighted by severity.
  • An overall rating that gives the most weight to your weakest assets.
  • One of the few vendors in this category that publishes its prices.
Good to know
  • The cheapest published paid plan works out at about $20,000 a year, which is priced for mid-market and enterprise teams.
  • The free instant score is a quick view; the detail behind each category needs a trial registration.

Free option: A free instant security score by short form, and a free website scan · Paid: From $1,750 a month (Vendor Risk) or $1,667 a month (Breach Risk), billed annually

Visit UpGuard

What a security rating is, and why your business already has one

A security rating is a grade or a score for a company’s cybersecurity, worked out from the outside. The rating company collects what anyone on the internet can see about your domain and your servers: how your email is protected against spoofing, how your website’s encryption is set up, which software versions your servers announce, which services are open to the internet, and whether your addresses show up in spam or malware data. It turns those observations into a letter grade or a number.

Because the data is public, nobody needs your permission to rate you. Large companies rate their suppliers this way before they sign a contract, and again every year. Cyber insurers watch the internet too: the insurer Coalition, for example, says it scans 4.5 billion IP addresses every month and actively monitors its policyholders’ internet-facing exposures. If you sell to larger firms, there is a good chance someone has already looked at your rating.

That is why the most useful thing a small business can do with a security rating is to look at its own, early, and fix what an outsider can see. The fixes are usually small settings, not new products: a DMARC record, a certificate renewal, a software update, a service that should not be open to the internet.

What outside-in ratings look at

The vendors use different names and weights, but they look at the same kinds of public evidence:

  • Email authentication: whether SPF, DKIM and DMARC stop someone sending email that pretends to come from your domain.
  • Encryption: whether your website’s certificate is valid, whether old TLS versions are still switched on, and whether plain HTTP redirects to HTTPS.
  • Software and patching: the server software, content management system and libraries your sites reveal, and whether those versions have known vulnerabilities or are out of support.
  • Exposed services: remote desktop, databases, admin panels and other services that are reachable from the internet when they should not be.
  • DNS and web configuration: security headers, files that should never be public, and DNS records that are broken or point at nothing.
  • Reputation: whether your IP addresses appear in spam, botnet or malware data (Bitsight, SecurityScorecard and Black Kite include this).

CyberScore Labs covers the first five of these in one free check. It does not use breach databases or malware feeds, so if your insurer or a customer cites a reputation finding, check that part in a platform that collects it, such as SecurityScorecard’s free account.

How the scores compare

Every vendor uses its own scale, and a score from one cannot be converted into another. What matters is the direction (higher is better on all of them) and the findings behind the number.

ToolScaleSee your own rating free?Built mainly for
CyberScore LabsLetter grade, A to FYes, free, no cardSmall businesses checking themselves
Bitsight250 to 900 (300 to 820 currently achievable)One-off emailed report, on requestEnterprise security, vendor-risk and insurance teams
Black KiteLetter grade, A to F, from 20 categoriesNot confirmedEnterprise vendor-risk teams
Panorays0 to 100 Cyber Posture RatingNot confirmedEnterprise vendor-risk teams
RiskRecon0 to 10, in A to F bandsWithin a 30-day trialVendor-risk programmes
SecurityScorecardLetter grade, A to FYes, free-forever accountEnterprise vendor-risk teams
UpGuardOut of 950 (instant score shown as A to F)Yes, free instant scoreMid-market and enterprise teams

Free self-checks versus paid rating platforms

A free self-check answers one question: what does an outsider see about my company, and what should I fix? That is what most small businesses need, and it is what CyberScore Labs, SecurityScorecard’s free account and UpGuard’s instant score give you.

Paid rating platforms answer a different question: how risky are the hundreds of suppliers we depend on? They add continuous monitoring of many companies, questionnaires, workflows for chasing suppliers, and reports for boards and auditors. They are sold to security and procurement teams at larger organisations. UpGuard, the only one of the six that publishes prices, starts at $1,667 a month billed annually for monitoring your own attack surface and $1,750 a month for vendor risk. The others quote on request.

A small business rarely needs the paid tier. If a large customer asks for your rating on a specific platform, open that platform’s free account, check the findings it shows, and use the dispute process for anything that is wrong. For everything else, a free outside-in check every month, and after any change to your website or email, keeps the obvious problems from building up.

How to choose a security rating tool

  1. Start with who is asking

    If a customer, partner or insurer has named a platform, use that platform’s free view of your own rating, because that is the grade they will see. If nobody has asked yet, start with a free check you can act on.

  2. Check that you can see your own rating

    Several platforms are built for watching suppliers, and their free accounts do not show your own company. SecurityScorecard and UpGuard do; Bitsight sends a one-off report; RiskRecon includes one in a 30-day trial.

  3. Look for the fix, not just the score

    A number tells you how worried to be. A finding with the exact setting to change tells you what to do on Monday. Pick a tool that explains each finding in words your IT person or web host can act on.

  4. Make sure it is passive

    Ratings should come from public data and ordinary requests. Anything that tries logins or attack traffic is a vulnerability scanner or a penetration test, which you should only run with clear permission and a plan.

  5. Check how disputes work

    Ratings sometimes attribute the wrong servers to a company. SecurityScorecard and Panorays say they respond to disputes within 24 hours; look for a clear way to correct findings before you rely on a score.

How to raise your security rating quickly

Most small-business ratings are pulled down by the same handful of settings, and most can be fixed in an afternoon:

  • Publish a DMARC record and move it from p=none towards p=quarantine or p=reject once your legitimate senders pass SPF or DKIM.
  • Renew and correctly install your HTTPS certificate, switch off TLS 1.0 and 1.1, and redirect every HTTP request to HTTPS.
  • Update your CMS, its plugins and your server software, and remove plugins and themes you no longer use.
  • Close services that should not face the internet, such as remote desktop, databases and device admin pages, or put them behind a VPN.
  • Add the common security headers and a security.txt file so researchers know how to reach you.
  • Remove old subdomains that point at services you no longer use, and dispute assets a rating wrongly says are yours.

Then check again. Ratings update on their own schedule, from daily to weekly, but a free check like CyberScore Labs shows the change straight away.

Why outside-in security matters for a small business

Small firms are not too small to be targeted. The UK government’s Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025/2026 found that 43% of UK businesses, and 46% of small businesses with 10 to 49 staff, reported a breach or attack in the previous 12 months. Phishing was by far the most common, experienced by 38% of businesses, which is exactly what DMARC is there to make harder.

Verizon’s 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report found that 31% of breaches now start with an exploited software vulnerability, ahead of stolen passwords, which is why outside-in ratings weigh patching so heavily. Its 2025 report found a third party involved in 30% of breaches, double the year before, and that is why larger companies keep rating their suppliers. The 2025 report also found ransomware in 88% of breaches at small and medium businesses, against 39% at large ones (Verizon counts fewer than 1,000 employees as small).

Frameworks point the same way. The UK’s Cyber Essentials scheme sets five basic controls, including secure configuration and security update management, and NIST’s Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 comes with quick-start guides written for small businesses. An outside-in check does not replace either, but it shows quickly whether the parts the internet can see are in order.

Questions to ask before you trust a rating

  • Which of these findings are about servers we actually own, and how do I correct the ones that are not?
  • What is the score based on, and is the method published?
  • How often is the rating refreshed, and how quickly will a fix show up?
  • Is the data collected passively, or does the tool send traffic that could look like an attack?
  • Can I see my own rating for free, or only rate other companies?
  • What does each finding mean in practice, and what exactly should I change?

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce published principles for fair and accurate security ratings that cover the same ground: transparency, a way to dispute and correct findings, accuracy and validation, model governance, independence and confidentiality.

Red flags

  • A score with no findings behind it, or findings with no explanation of how to fix them.
  • No way to dispute an asset that is not yours.
  • A "free rating" that turns out to be a sales call before you see anything.
  • A tool that wants to scan ports or try logins against your systems without a clear agreement in writing.
  • Claims to measure things an outside-in rating cannot see, such as your staff training or your backups, without asking you.

How we compared security rating tools

  • Can a small business see its own rating?

    For free, without a sales call, and as often as it needs.

  • What the rating covers

    Email security, encryption, software and patching, exposed services and configuration, from public data.

  • Whether it tells you what to fix

    Findings in plain English with the setting to change, not just a number.

  • Price transparency

    Whether the vendor publishes prices, and what the entry plan costs.

  • Method and disputes

    Whether the scoring method is explained and wrong findings can be corrected.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best security rating tool for a small business?

CyberScore Labs is our pick for small businesses. One free check grades your email security, website, known vulnerabilities and exposed services in about 60 seconds, explains each finding in plain English with the exact fix, needs no credit card and never sends attack traffic. If a customer uses a specific platform, also open its free view: SecurityScorecard and UpGuard both let you see your own rating for free.

Can I see my SecurityScorecard rating for free?

Yes. SecurityScorecard offers a free-forever account that includes the rating for your own domain, an overview of open issues and alerts when your score changes, and it lets you dispute findings. Monitoring other companies and the deeper features are paid.

What is a Bitsight score, and what range does it use?

Bitsight rates companies on a scale from 250 to 900, which it compares to a credit score; higher is better, and the range currently achievable is 300 to 820. You can request a free one-off report on your own organisation through a form on Bitsight’s site.

How are security ratings calculated?

From outside-in data: what anyone can see about your domain and servers, such as email authentication, certificates and TLS, software versions, open services and, for some vendors, spam and malware data. Each vendor weights these differently, so a score from one platform cannot be converted into another’s.

Why would a customer or an insurer check my security rating?

Larger companies rate their suppliers before and during a contract, because suppliers are a common way in: Verizon found a third party involved in 30% of breaches in its 2025 report. Insurers watch internet-facing risk too; Coalition says it scans 4.5 billion IP addresses a month and monitors policyholders’ exposures.

How do I improve my security rating quickly?

Fix what the internet can see: publish and enforce DMARC, renew your certificate and switch off old TLS versions, update your CMS, plugins and server software, close services that should not be public, add security headers, remove unused subdomains, and dispute assets that are not yours. Then run a free check again to confirm.

Is a security rating the same as a penetration test?

No. A rating reads public information and makes ordinary requests, so it shows what any outsider can see. A penetration test is an authorised attempt to break in, done by specialists with your written permission, and it finds problems a rating cannot, such as flaws behind a login.

Are security ratings accurate?

They are only as good as the vendor’s attribution of servers to your company and its checks. Mistakes happen, which is why the U.S. Chamber of Commerce’s principles for security ratings include a way to dispute and correct findings. Check the findings behind any score before you act on it.

Which security rating tools publish their prices?

Of the six enterprise platforms in this guide, only UpGuard publishes prices: from $1,667 a month for Breach Risk and $1,750 a month for Vendor Risk, billed annually. Bitsight, Black Kite, Panorays, RiskRecon and SecurityScorecard quote on request. CyberScore Labs is free.

Is CyberScore Labs really free?

Yes. The check is free and needs no credit card; you give your domain and an email address so we can show and send the report. If you want help fixing what it finds, you can ask us, and that part is up to you.

Will the CyberScore Labs check disrupt my website or email?

No. It reads public DNS records, connects once over HTTPS to read your certificate and makes a handful of ordinary web requests, about what one visitor would. It never logs in, never scans your ports and never sends attack traffic.

See the grade an outsider sees

Check your domain free: email security, website, known vulnerabilities and exposed services, graded A to F, with the fix for every finding. About 60 seconds, no credit card.

Run the free check

Sources

Checked on 21 November 2026. Prices and free plans change; check the vendor's page before you buy.

  1. CyberScore Labs: what the free check reads (homepage FAQ)
  2. Bitsight: security ratings snapshot report (free report for your own organisation)
  3. Bitsight: the definitive guide to Bitsight security ratings
  4. Bitsight: announcing Bitsight and Moody's partnership (2021)
  5. Black Kite: cyber risk rating explained
  6. Black Kite: free cyber risk assessment
  7. Panorays: Cyber Posture Rating explained
  8. Panorays: free account
  9. RiskRecon: free 30-day trial (Know your portfolio)
  10. Mastercard: Mastercard acquires RiskRecon (December 2019)
  11. Mastercard Developers: RiskRecon API, rating bands
  12. SecurityScorecard: security ratings
  13. SecurityScorecard: pricing and the free-forever account
  14. UpGuard: how security ratings work
  15. UpGuard: pricing
  16. UpGuard: free instant security score
  17. UK DSIT: Cyber Security Breaches Survey 2025/2026
  18. Verizon: 2026 Data Breach Investigations Report
  19. Verizon: 2025 Data Breach Investigations Report, news release
  20. Verizon: 2025 DBIR small and medium business snapshot (PDF)
  21. U.S. Chamber of Commerce: principles for fair and accurate security ratings
  22. NCSC: Cyber Essentials overview
  23. NIST: Cybersecurity Framework 2.0 released (February 2024)
  24. Coalition: active monitoring